Rye Police Bust Two Suspected of 35 Area Burglaries

Greenwich man, accomplice accused of commercial burglaries committed during the region's power outages.


Two Connecticut men—including a Greenwich resident—have been arrested for what Rye, NY police say was a six-day spree that involved 35 burglaries of area businesses.

The suspects, identified as John F. Tully, 21, of Greenwich, and Robert M. Smith, 20, of Fairfield, are suspected of burglarizing 35 businesses from Harrison, NY to Wilton from Nov. 1 until Nov. 6 when they were arrested on Midland Avenue in Rye, according to Rye Police.

Tully and Smith indicated to police they took advantage of the area’s widespread power outages to break doors and windows of small businesses and steal cash and cigarettes, according to Rye City Police Commissioner William Connors.

The two are accused of burglarizing the Post Road Market, the Oakland Beach Deli, Rye Beverage, Boston Post Road and Lamberti’s Service Station. They are accused of attempting to break in to Shell at 1141 Boston Post Rd., and Belluscio’s Retaurant on Midland Avenue. They allegedly took $100 and 10 cartons of cigarettes from Post Road Market; and $300 cash and equipment from Lamberti’s, and damaging cameras and wiring at Oakland Beach Deli.

They have been charged with four counts of third-degree burglary and two counts of attempted third-degree burglary for their crimes in Rye. Tully and Smith are accused of two burglaries in Harrison, one in North Castle, eight in Greenwich, 15 in Fairfield, two in Wilton, and one in Redding, Connors said.

The two were arraigned on Nov. 6 in Rye City Court and are being held without bail in Westchester County Jail.

Around 4 a.m. on Nov. 6 a burglary alarm at the Oakland Beach deli alerted police to a problem. Officers Franco Compagnone and Christine Incalcatera noticed the front door was kicked in and the business had been entered. As they canvassed the crime area they noticed a car parked in the middle of the road outside of Belluscio’s Restaurant at 352 Midland Ave.

The car pulled away into a driveway on Midland Avenue. When approached by police the two suspects claimed they lived at that address. But while officer Compagnone was shining his light on the suspects he noticed one suspects pants was reflecting the light.

The pants were filled with shards of glass allegedly from the windows of businesses they had burglarized, Connors explained.

“Officer Compagnone did a fabulous job,” Connors said. “He had good observations and took good action.”

Area agencies were notified and the Rye City police department had a steady stream of detectives from Connecticut agencies in to interview the suspects.

“Not often do we get to apprehend people who have committed so many crimes,” Connors said. “Especially under these circumstances when they are striking people at their most vulnerable time.”

Rye police have increased their personnel during evening hours when houses are dark and have not experienced any other burglaries, Connors said.

When contacted Thursday night, Greenwich Police would not comment on the arrests or the burglaries in town.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something